The potential No. 1 picks in inaugural MLB draft lottery

by

The primary-ever MLB draft lottery is about to happen on the winter conferences tonight, so we’ll know the highest order of the 2023 MLB draft, to be held in July on the All-Star festivities in Seattle.

Tuesday evening’s lottery will decide the highest six picks within the draft, and the Washington Nationals, Oakland Athletics and Pittsburgh Pirates, who all misplaced 100 or extra video games, have the best odds — 16.5% — of getting the highest decide.

With that in thoughts, it is an ideal time to have a look at the draft prospects whom groups might be eyeing on the prime.

This early within the draft course of, there is a problem in making an attempt to nail down the highest of the draft — a broadly held favourite who will look foolish on reflection, or a participant who has an unexpected leap in means or an injury-marred season.

That is why I am trying on the discipline in tiers: Most conversations I’ve had pinpointed a consensus prime group, then a handful of seemingly challengers if issues break proper for them this spring. (You can watch nearly the entire prime faculty gamers all spring on ESPN+ since they’re concentrated within the SEC!)

Since there is not a transparent, slam-dunk No. 1 prospect, which crew wins the primary decide and the precise order of the draft can have a big affect on who goes early. In recent times, we have seen that model-focused groups — or these trying to soak each ounce of worth out of the system — will take a nonconsensus expertise first to arrange the remainder of their draft. This yr, although, there is not a crew within the prime 10 of the lottery odds that leans closely on its draft mannequin (Pirates and Detroit Tigers most likely do probably the most) and there are a variety of groups extra inclined to a standard method (Nationals, Kansas City Royals, Colorado Rockies), so signing the highest decide for below-slot worth is rather less seemingly this yr than in earlier years.

The consensus group

Dylan Crews, OF, LSU
Wyatt Langford, OF, Florida

I will group the SEC outfielders collectively since they’re related and could be the highest two candidates to go 1-1 at this level.

Like many prime picks, Crews has an extended historical past of efficiency; he was seen as among the finest in his class by his sophomore yr of highschool. He seemed ticketed to go within the late-first to compensation rounds within the pandemic-shortened 2020 MLB draft and had an enormous signing bonus ask, increased than the place he was projected. Given his outsized expectations and certain end result within the draft, he pulled his identify out early, so he by no means has been topic to the complete course of.

Crews’ headline means is plus-plus uncooked energy that comes from massive bat velocity. He additionally has robust manufacturing in the very best league in beginner baseball. The considerations about him are related to those who existed out of highschool, however they’re clearly a lot smaller now: He is most likely a nook outfielder quite than a middle fielder, and it is unclear if he’ll be a great or merely OK hitter for common, with a great however not nice method. To be clear, this can be a actual nitpick.

Langford, on the opposite finish of the spectrum, was nameless his freshman yr at Florida as a frivolously regarded backup catcher with 4 at-bats all season. He then jumped to Crews’ degree with a scorching-hot sophomore yr in 2022. Langford is an above-average runner who will flash a plus run time and has above-average-to-plus uncooked energy. He would not have a 70-grade instrument and the monitor file is only one season, however there’s an opportunity that by draft time he is seen as a great outfielder (possibly even a middle fielder?) with 25-homer upside and among the finest two-year faculty efficiency runs in latest reminiscence.

To place all of this in context statistically, Langford was the common left fielder for the Gators final yr and hit .355/.447/.719 with 26 homers, 36 walks and 44 strikeouts in 256 at-bats; Crews hit .349/.463/.691 with 22 homers, 42 walks, and 56 strikeouts in 249 at-bats.

And for historic context, former Florida 3B Jonathan India‘s breakthrough draft yr efficiency that took him from a third-rounder originally of the 2018 season to the No. 5 decide on the finish of the yr was .350/.497/.717 with 21 homers, 60 walks and 56 strikeouts in 226 at-bats. One factor I observed when bearing down on each of them on the SEC match final yr is that Langford has one of many easiest swings you possibly can think about, harking back to former Gator Pete Alonso, whereas Crews is in a squat and strikes round much more within the field, trying like a batter with a higher-maintenance swing topic to streakier efficiency.

So, if Crews and Langford merely maintain serve and mainly repeat what they did final yr (nearly each elite prospect on this scenario improves their stat line of their draft yr), they’re robust bets for the highest three to 5 picks. As pedigreed SEC bats with some defensive worth, they’re precisely what groups wish to take with excessive picks, so the percentages are stacked of their favor.

That stated, if both falls off a bit or simply has a foul yr, there’s yet one more SEC place participant with the one variable in his favor that Crews and Langford haven’t got.

Jacob Gonzalez, SS, Ole Miss

Ending off the SEC taste (it is barbecue, for those who have been questioning) on the prime, we’ve Gonzalez. Now, ideally, groups need that elite SEC hitter with pedigree and efficiency who can play up the center, and Gonzalez has the very best probability of this group to do all three. He grew into his energy in his sophomore yr — hitting .273/.405/.558 with 18 homers, 50 walks and 32 strikeouts in 242 at-bats — and he is a lefty-hitting shortstop out of a Southern California highschool who bought early-round consideration within the 2021 draft.

His swing is slightly funky (he bails towards first base) and he is not a slam-dunk above-average defensive shortstop for each crew, so the “bear” case is he is only a good ballplayer with a bunch of above-average qualities who will play within the infield. For the “bull” case, the funk appears someplace from unimportant to fixable. You would possibly undertaking him as an enormous leaguer with 20ish homers as an on a regular basis shortstop — and there are solely eight to 12 of these at any given time.

Chase Dollander, RHP, Tennessee

The opposite factor each crew desires on the prime of the draft is a high-probability ace. Dollander shouldn’t be fairly at that Stephen Strasburg/David Price space the place ace is the anticipated end result, however scouts will probably be tossing that phrase round all spring making an attempt to determine the place he falls on this hierarchy. After which in addition they have to think about the harrowing possibilities of harm or regression, as latest top-of-the-draft potential ace from the SEC Jack Leiter has proven.

Bodily and in his supply, Dollander has a glance much like Jacob deGrom. He’ll sit 94-98 mph, combine in a slider and curveball which might be each above-average to plus and an above-average changeup with management you possibly can undertaking at starter high quality. He carved the SEC final yr (79.0 IP with 14 GS, 50 H, 13 BB, 108 Okay for a 2.39 ERA, and 10-0 file) after transferring from Georgia Southern, the place he flew beneath the radar. His breaking ball high quality and command are two variables to control all spring as Dollander can even get into the “extra hittable than you’d assume” space for stretches in opposition to prime competitors with a great recreation plan. Once more, that is additionally very nitpicky, however these are the conversations scouts are having proper now.

Others within the combine

Max Clark, OF, Franklin HS (Ind.), Vanderbilt commit
Walker Jenkins, OF, South Brunswick HS (N.C.), North Carolina commit

For some, Clark and/or Jenkins belong within the prime group. They have been grouped collectively for at the very least a yr as the 2 prime prep bats on this class. Clark is a plus-running middle fielder with fast-twitch athleticism, superior really feel for contact and stable uncooked energy for that profile, together with a colourful character. Jenkins has a possible plus hit/energy mixture as his promoting level in a basic right-field profile and tons of historical past. They’re going to want massive springs to leap over the entire SEC sorts within the first group, however each are robust bets to land someplace within the prime 10 picks both means.

3B Aidan Miller, Mitchell HS (Fla.), Arkansas commit
SS Arjun Nimmala, Strawberry Crest HS (Fla.), Florida State commit

Miller has lengthy been within the dialog on the prime of this class and suits into the Josh Donaldson-type mildew of a 3rd baseman with enormous bat velocity and energy. This summer season he confirmed extra bat management, whereas his primary battle will probably be making an attempt to win over model-heavy groups that maintain his age (19.1 on draft day) in opposition to him. If you would like to argue in opposition to the way in which some groups use age in opposition to gamers (Brett Baty is a notable miss for that group), check out Miller crushing a long home run at age 15.

Nimmala is on the opposite finish of the age spectrum — 17.8 on draft day, whereas one thing like 18.3 is common for a drafted excessive schooler. That is an enormous empirical edge primarily based on draft historical past, so he’ll be championed by mannequin groups but in addition has loads of scouting enchantment with fast-twitch athleticism and a basic shortstop profile. Many anticipate him to have a Keoni Cavaco-like rise (the thirteenth total decide in 2019 who got here out of nowhere) this spring, with an opportunity for much more.

With the pair taking part in in Florida after a powerful summer season, they’re going to be priorities and each will probably be scouted laborious in February and early March by these on the town for spring coaching and/or ready for the climate to thaw up north. This provides them loads of time to begin a spring-long cost up the board with waves of particular assistants and GMs flying in to verify or deny the early hunches of scouts.

Gamers up north usually have solely a month of video games with good sufficient climate for that course of to happen and face notable competitors just a few instances per spring, so that they have hassle creating that narrative and having sufficient runway to maneuver up the board within the spring. This is the reason some draft mannequin groups will increase these northern gamers to account for them being underdrafted at instances; Mike Trout is a notable instance.

Jacob Wilson, SS, Grand Canyon
Enrique Bradfield, CF, Vanderbilt
Brayden Taylor, SS, TCU
Kevin McGonigle, SS, Monsignor Bonner HS (Pa.), Auburn commit

These 4 are lower-upside sorts, because of an absence of game-changing energy, who haven’t got an amazing shot to get all the way in which as much as the highest decide however appear more likely to go within the prime dozen picks.

Wilson is the son of longtime massive leaguer Jack Wilson and has the type of lanky body the place you possibly can think about energy coming ultimately, nevertheless it is not there but, whereas the bat and glove are. Bradfield is a throwback kind as a top-of-the-scale 80-runner whom scouts have seen since his freshman yr in highschool in the identical lineup as Mets 3B Mark Vientos and Crimson Sox 1B Triston Casas at American Heritage. Bradfield actually is aware of the best way to use his velocity in all phases, he has nice really feel for the sport and he is including extra energy to his recreation, however he is all the time going to be a velocity/protection/contact-type initially. Taylor is a plus hitter with a plus method and can seemingly slide over to 3rd base long-term; you are hoping the facility will play to common. McGonigle can be unlikely to be a shortstop long-term and is not that massive, however he might need been probably the most constant hitter within the prep class all summer season, with a 15-20 homer upside if all of it clicks.


Leave a Comment